An Idea to Reshape

3 February 2011

A Times article last Saturday gave a pretty harsh critique of, the search giant’s philanthropic wing. Begun in 2004 with grand dreams of reinventing philanthropy and revolutionizing the non-profit world by leveraging Google’s powerful technological assets and unconventional approach to problems, DotOrg has foundered. Today, it operates not unlike a “conventional corporate philanthropy,” doling out cash to big nonprofits, with occasional cool, innovative projects like Flu Trends and Earth Engine. The article blames this on shifting, sometimes undependable leadership, and a disconnect between the social types of DotOrg and engineers of the DotCom.

The more core problem with, it seems, is their engineering-centric approach to social change. This is a widely-known, and yet very common mistake in the tech-for-development world. People get a powerful tool in their hands, and start looking for problems it can solve, rather than the other way around: addressing a specific problem, and thinking about how to solve it. To be sure, mobile phones and other new technologies have proven valuable tools for solving certain types of social problems, but only by taking a problem-centric, rather than solution-centric approach is any progress likely to be made. has been a consistent offender of this rule; after their brilliant algorithm solved the problem of search, it was easy to think that Google engineers could tackle any problem, provided they coded hard enough. But in the words of Professor Laurence Simon, quoted in the article: “there isn’t any algorithm that’s going to eradicate guinea worm.”

To put it another way, Google’s approach to philanthropy and global development was top-down. They thought that by creating super tools and technologies while sitting in Mountain View, lives in Haiti, Liberia, and India would be transformed. But solving vexing global problems doesn’t usually work that way.  Usually, development is successful when it happens bottom-up: when communities or countries identify problems, imagine solutions, and implement their ideas. The does not describe the DotOrg approach to date. From the article:

Some DotOrg staff members with traditional nonprofit backgrounds proposed a system to track drugs for diseases like malaria and tuberculosis through the supply chain…

The plan never went anywhere, however, because text-messaging was not sophisticated enough to challenge Google’s engineers.

In other words, the approach was too bottom-up to appeal to Google’s tech-centric sensibilities.

But the good and well-meaning Googlers shouldn’t be discouraged. Provided they are willing to re-think their approach to development, can offer, at once, a bottom-up, problem-centric approach to global challenges, while at the same time leverage Google’s formidable monetary and technological assets in unconventional ways. What follows is one idea for how DotOrg can do this.

iHubAbout a year ago, a group of Kenyan technologists got together and founded the iHub, a place for techies to come together in Nairobi, share workspace, collaborate, learn, and find investment for their ideas.  With initial funding from the Omidyar Network, and riding high on the growing success and global recognition of Ushahidi, the successful SMS-based mapping application developed in Kenya in 2007, the iHub has helped knock down the perception of Africa as strictly a consumer-but not producer-of technology.  Since its founding, the concept of the iHub has been mimicked across sub-Saharan Africa, with similar collaboration spaces established in Uganda, Nigeria, Cameroon, and elsewhere, all helping promote and encourage African technologists and connecting them with capital.

Last summer, in partnership with the iHub and Appfrica Labs, a Ugandan technology and innovation space, the U.S. State Department ran an app contest called Apps<4>Africa, in which they challenged African software developers to write mobile phone apps that would benefit the people of Africa. The winning app, written by a member of the iHub, was called iCow, and is a voice-based mobile app that “helps farmers track the estrus stages of their cows,” with the hopes of allowing them to better manage breeding in their herd. Other apps took on problems of governmental corruption, maternal health, small-scale finance and banking, among a wide array of very real challenges in everyday life for African citizens.

These tech hubs are remarkable not just as technology institutions, but as institutions of civil society and entrepreneurial vibrancy as well. For any developing country to overcome poverty and emerge as a successful middle-income state, a strong civil society and a robust economy are two essential ingredients.  By serving as places for tech-savvy citizens to come together and vectors for investment to reach entrepreneurs and the iHub and its followers are incubators for both of these things. If wants to create a meaningful impact on global development while leveraging their position as one of the world’s premier tech companies, these technology hubs are one very unconventional way to go about it.  Here’s how:

- Building Hubs: Right now, the iHub is supported financially by Ushahidi. Not every developing country has such a successful project so well positioned to be the convener and financier of a technology hub. DotOrg could help finance existing hubs, while creating and building new hubs throughout the developing world, bringing together local developers, business interests and social actors to innovate and collaborate.

- App Contests & More: An app contest is a cheap and easy project to run, but can serve as a valuable incentive for inexperienced developers to try their hand at entrepreneurship, while also making for great publicity-both for the sponsor and the winning developers. Small scale projects like app contests can help put technology hubs on the map, identify the most promising engineers, and launch a few useful new technologies, to boot.  

- Talent Sharing: From the inception of DotOrg, Google has sought to leverage the power of their staff: a collection of some of the best software developers in the world. But sitting in Mountain View, the developers themselves have had little connection to the challenges of people in the developing world. Why not create fellowships for their talented engineers to spend time in a foreign technology hub, teaching young developers and helping build and improve nascent projects.

- Venture Capital: Rather than seeking to build their own world-saving tools or pouring money into “conventional” philanthropic projects, DotOrg should invest in the best of the innumerable homegrown ideas for technology development. Active tech hubs are gold mines of entrepreneurs and ideas, and as a foundation, DotOrg can make more investments and accept a higher degree of risk than a strictly for-profit VC investor. If the successful projects are explicitly focused on improving social conditions, so much the better, but either way, investment capital is a key to economic development anywhere.

By engaging with the burgeoning technology hubs in Africa, helping to create new ones throughout the developing world, and using the hubs as platforms for sharing their technological and monetary assets, could have a very real impact in helping poor countries develop from the bottom up.  Supporting the private sector-whether tech-based social enterprises or straight-up for-profit technology companies-and helping strengthen civil society are two somewhat unconventional yet crucially important elements of global development. And DotOrg has a unique comparative advantage in doing so through technology.

What’s more, Google can see this endeavor as beneficial to their bottom line. Robust technology hubs around the world will eventually yield products that the company may want to acquire for itself-so that it can build its own business in the developing world. Additionally, technology hubs will provide a valuable talent pool for future hiring. Google recently brought on Ory Okolloh as their policy manager for Africa; before joining Google, Ory was one of the founders of Ushahidi and involved with the iHub in Nairobi.  With a robust network of technology hubs around the world, Google will have early access to the best ideas and people, and DotOrg will live up to its promise of operating in part as a for-profit entity.

For many in the development world, has been a bit of a disappointment after the great hopes surrounding its launch. A few scattered projects have made an impact, and the company deserves applause for the level of its philanthropy alone-Google donated $184 million last year-but DotOrg has greater potential.  The iHub is already on the company’s radar: Google is hosting a “mapping party” there next week for women working in tech and social development.  If the foundation can overcome its tech-centric, solution-oriented approach to global change, and instead leverage its advantages in ways that facilitate bottom-up development, could become a real leader in the field.

54 Responses to An Idea to Reshape
  1. Hortense says:

    Reed bed technology has a low price of entry and minimal daily functional and upkeep
    costs. * Edwin Hubbel Chapin once said, “Every action of our lives touches on. Many of the Earthships have propane tanks for cooking and a backup hot water supply; these are the only utility bills.

  2. Lilly says:

    We had better use Msconfig or ask help from Windows optimization. Reed beds
    present sludge dewatering by plant consumption, evapotranspiration, and
    drainage. It is not known what prompted officials to drain that specific septic tank looking for Noah’s body.

  3. Millie says:

    He spotted a Sears snow cruiser that was only made from 1965 to 1972 and is truly a collector’s item.
    This tool is a long, hollow, transparent piece of plastic branded with one-foot accretion. Nitrogen-deficient
    grass invites the growth of moss.

  4. Shanna says:

    As a homeowner, you will have maintenance and other related costs to keep your drain system running efficiently.
    Pipes and fittings are often made of the same base material such
    as copper, steel, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC).
    Experience the difference an experienced, reliable home theater setup company makes.

  5. Jens says:

    Because of this capability, this equipment is mainly used in drainage cleaning where solids have already mixed in with the fluids.
    Reed beds present sludge dewatering by plant consumption, evapotranspiration, and drainage.
    It is not known what prompted officials to drain that specific septic tank looking for Noah’s body.

  6. Lashunda says:

    Because of this capability, this equipment is mainly used in drainage cleaning where solids
    have already mixed in with the fluids. Pipes and fittings
    are often made of the same base material such as copper,
    steel, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC).
    It is not known what prompted officials to drain that specific septic tank
    looking for Noah’s body.

  7. Stanley says:

    About The – Author: Harris – Noah is an expert author
    on pet products related topics and currently workingfor.
    Pipes and fittings are often made of the same base material such as copper, steel, polyvinyl
    chloride (PVC), and chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC).
    While both parents were charged, one of the charges that the boy’s mother is facing is more
    serious than what the boy’s father is facing, according to WUSA-9 on April 3.

  8. There are far too many out there to just search through each day.
    Its member companies manufacture popular national brands as well as the store
    brands marketed by major supermarkets, drug stores and discount chains.

    Another important fact why this disease is treated differently from conventional illnesses and why adrenal fatigue supplements are different from conventional medicine
    lays in the spectrum which it deals with.

  9. Allen says:

    Also, you should start with a low dosage and work your way up.
    Sometimes eating of bad calories result in making the dieter overweight which is really a matter of concern because it
    directly targets the working efficiency of its user.
    ‘Were the supplements tested independently for purity and strength.

  10. Harvey says:

    The fact is that nowadays there are hundreds if not thousands of different
    types of dog supplements and treats that you
    can buy today. Sometimes eating of bad calories result in making
    the dieter overweight which is really a matter of concern because it directly targets the working efficiency of its user.
    Do a simple search on Google or Amazon for a keyword like “dog supplements” and instantly you will get hundreds of thousands
    of results.

  11. Katherin says:

    Most of those supplements work by stopping the cause
    of baldness. Good cholesterol or HDL helps your body
    rid itself of dietary cholesterol. Research strongly suggests that people with high
    levels of Omega-3 fatty acids in their blood experience positive brain qualities such as fewer
    signs of blood flow obstructions and fewer episodes
    of Dementia.

  12. Rodger says:

    “The old saying used to be diagnosed and adios, and now that spectrum has completely changed. In fact the height of a teenager increases dramatically. Research strongly suggests that people with high levels of Omega-3 fatty acids in their blood experience positive brain qualities such as fewer signs of blood flow obstructions and fewer episodes of Dementia.

  13. Jerrold says:

    In just a few days, you can have your shop up and running with Zen Cart.
    No software to buy, no code to learn, all you need is to be a little Internet savvy and know how
    to click your mouse. I discovered the way to make money on the internet.

  14. m88 says:

    It’s an remarrkable piece of writing in support off all the online viewers; they will get benefit from
    it I am sure.

  15. Fausto says:

    The website will also serve as a portal for all things
    convention related, from a countdown clock to information on logistics, credentials, media walkthroughs and housing.
    However, because they are free, users cannot have a custom
    domain name, rather the URL will be [insertname]. I discovered the way
    to make money on the internet.

  16. Rafaela says:

    In just a few days, you can have your shop up and running with Zen Cart.
    Small claims court cases are much cheaper than superior court cases for both the plaintiff (the
    person doing the suing) and the defendant (the person being sued) because the
    parties are not allowed to have any attorneys represent them and other rules that simplify the lawsuit process, making the whole thing much cheaper, faster, and easier.

    Predicting i – Phone 6: Size, features and release date.

  17. Chi says:

    If you are going to do affiliate marketing long term this is definitely the way
    to go. On the other hand, if the person is an early
    adopter, likes to make a statement or wants a personalized gift, then she
    will likely search the Internet. For this reason, the content should be drafted carefully, because
    interactive content tend the social media networkers to revisit social
    media fronts.

  18. One thing you can do is have planned savings, where you set aside a certain percentage of your
    income into this account. Securing your finances should be one of three goals any retiree should
    be looking at. once you found the suitable site you
    have further discuss with your investment broker.

  19. People who choose not to use an inspector often run into problems once they move in and discover issues with plumbing, damp, mold or other serious
    defects that probably would have dissuaded them from buying the home to begin with.
    Buenos qualified plumbers are always in high demand and short-term gain can be a serious problem.
    It might be best if you fix as much as possible while you hold the plumber at your residence.

  20. Asking questions are actually good thing if you are not understanding anything completely, but this
    piece of writing gives good understanding yet.

  21. says:

    Do you have the patience to take the stain out
    of the couch or the carpet. Some of the biodegradable ingredients in Fiber-Glo include grapefruit seed
    and orange peel extract. Relax and let these Cleaning Companies provide House Cleaning Services San Diego.

  22. Buying fixed assets like land and buildings may be challenging these days.

    To make sure that you use the proper forms when you are deciding
    how to remove a deceased person from a property deed, you
    must know the various deed types. You got into real estate because you want the big

  23. jody l kriss says:

    To increase the number of referrals that come your way, you need to be sure to provide excellent customer service and then simply ask for the names of a few people who may be interested in your services when you
    have closed the deal. This allows you to concentrate on multiple deals at one time.

    Owning Luxury Real Estate in Boca Raton and Delray
    Beach is your gateway to a leisurely life of unparalleled luxury.

  24. Matcha says:

    Cooking typically leaches vital nutrients and vitamins out
    of food. In Connecticut, an estimated $856 million in adult medical expenditures are attributable to
    obesity each year. So when trying to reach your
    weight loss goals, try to start in the winter months and
    you’ll have jump started the weight loss process.

  25. Raspberry Pi says:

    Asking questions are in fact good thing if you are not understanding something totally, except this article offers good understanding even.

  26. Emely says:

    Comenzó su carrera en los 50′s en las gacetas de tendencia
    Vogue, Life y Haper’s Bazaar.

  27. go now says:

    Traditional wooden buildings can sway and crack under the forces of
    inclement weather and strong winds, possibly causing damage to your
    precious possessions inside. If you are considering buying a metal garage to
    use as a workshop or a home office, you need to consider what storage you require.
    As each UPS store is an independent franchise, check before showing up with a truckload of the packing material.

  28. Jere says:

    Una carroza tirada por pavos reales, con uno de ellos a su lado,
    completaba sus atributos.

  29. This is the initial bachelorette event of
    my group so I will most definitely consuming Phoenix az Digital Printing again for all future screen printing

  30. If someday you are late paying financing installations as well as
    we got involved iin trouble of legislation because oof this, we must immediately contact Dallas insolvency
    attorney too conserve uss from that bad situations.

  31. Pour rappel, une femme a besoin de 1800 kcal par jour et un homme de 2000 kcal.

  32. Though the species was last sighted 1912, it was officially declared extinct only 2013 after all the attempts to find it its habitat failed to yield desired result.

  33. Colleen says:

    Actualmente trabaja en su galería Towel Series en la que
    retrató a más de 50 conocidos, incluyendo modelos de Victoria`s Secret la actriz Natalie Portman (foto), entre varias famosas del cine.

  34. Hoy, Francisca Roura se sienta para charlar sobre la fotografía, los niños y el negocio de la fotografía
    social a lo largo de sus doce años de trabajo como fotógrafa.

  35. Davis says:

    Estudio Lmental, fotografía y vídeo para tu boda, Cubrimos bodas
    en Nuevo Vallarta, Puerto Vallarta, Punto de Mita, Punta Monterrey, Sayulita, San Pancho, San Francisco,

  36. face says:

    wrinkle correction serum

  37. Which stands to benefit from the Foodopoly are DuPont, Monsanto, Lobbyists, Congress plus food and seeds companies.
    Naturally , these can become done at any time of the day.

    Avoid put excessive pressure on yourself simply by “demanding”
    that you simply act and feel a certain way.

  38. master cleanse diet beyonce forskolin herbal trim tea pure green coffee extract at walmart gmc acadia denali awd mangosteen queen of the fruits of the flesh hoodia gordonii history of halloween and christianity metamucil fiber ingredients chitosan ointment synonym guar gum 500g pure powder mimosa lipozene nausea causes glucomannan powder vs capsules

  39. Alright misc fappers …I’m giving away brand new Fleshlight, lube, cleaning solution, and instruction booklet.

  40. Arturo says:

    Ese valor triplica el tiempo que tardó el aficionado, con una media de dos
    minutos y 43 segundos entre las tres fotografías, en captar la mejor imagen.

  41. Vineyard Tourts are excellent for Valentine’s Day, bachelorette celebrations,
    a girl’s weekend, Mother’s Day, industrial benefits or aany type of special event tnat is worthy of
    an unuque treat!

  42. siehe hier says:

    Ein extra Gadget der Plugs ist die Vibration.

  43. Harriett says:

    You probably offer flyers and brochures as downloads out
    of your website. Tell your visitors far ahead of time where your
    next art show, craft market or gallery showing will be.
    This may be the best online internet marketing affiliate program around the net.

  44. Eine Reihe frankobelgischer Alben, die man auch den Graphic Novels zurechnen kann, wurden ebenfalls der Presse erwähnt.

  45. Sein großen Gartentisch und unter ihr noch irgendetwas zu essen und ihr Schlafzimmer, wo Jens und schließlich meinem Ständer nuckelte.

  46. pendant deux semaines des villes de taille moyenne et il a cassé us.The lendemain, il trouve un lot qui va faire amende plaisanterie. Il a été utilisé des terrains de jeux de fourrure aschool, mais l’école a été déplacée et l’ancien bâtiment Isto être démoli. Il a loué l’endroit pas cher. Et il va et parle thegas société en lui donnant le crédit pour combler ce ballon. Ce que je keptwondering ce qui était l’utilisation de son remplissage, la fourrure aucun des quatre d’entre nous hadever a augmenté dans un. Et quand je vu les tracts qu’il avait fait imprimer Iwondered autant plus. Ils lisent comme follers: Kirbys Komedy Kompany et Open Air CircusPresenting un personnel Peerless de AttractionsGreatest artistique dans la Galaxie de Gaiety, isHartley L. KirbyMonologuist et ménestrel, danseuse et vaudevillian dans ses terpsichoreantravesties, burlesques porteurs, imitations inimitables,

  47. Entsprechend werden ebenfalls alle Mitglieder gefragt, ob eine Akzeptanz für eine Partnerschaft oder Freundschaft mit einem hochsensiblem Gleichklang-Mitglied besteht.

  48. comme Dido toCarthage, comme Manco Cassae et Mama Belle à l’Amérique, et ils havesometimes oubliés quand. Au moins, ils sont plus sages, plus fort, plus juste, thanthe aborigènes. Ils sont à themas Jacques Cartier était aux dieux Indiansof Canadaas. Ils ne sont pas sûrs qu’elles ne sont pas fromgods descendus. Ils sont les enfants du soleil, ou de ce pas. Les enfants oflight, qui ray à cette lumière comme ils ont, sur l’obscurité de theirsubjects. Ils sont d’abord, sans doute, civilisateurs, pas vainqueurs. Car, iftradition vaut anythingand on n’a rien d’autre à aller uponthey AREAT premier peu nombreux. Ils viennent comme des colons, ou même comme sages simples. Ilest, dans toute tradition, pas le nombre qui influencent quelques-uns, mais les rares whoinfluence les aristocraties many.So, dans le vrai sens, sont formed.But le plus élevé

  49. Bei mir wird sie regelmässig pur genommen.

  50. dieser kerl says:

    Du wirst das morgen und alles was danach kommt schaffen und die Adventszeit wird bestimmt auch schön für Dich werden, da bin ich mir sicher.

  51. Auffällig ist nämlich, dass keine nachhaltige Sanierung der Wirtschaft gelang, sondern nur ein Sektor, nämlich die Landwirtschaft, sich längerfristig konsolidieren konnte.

  52. A Parque Social Desentupidora tem equipamentos modernos para hidrojateamentos com hidro jato portátil em difícil acesso para encanamentos
    de 040 até 200 mm de forma deixando encanamento limpo e prevenido.

  53. Die Fotzen Cams zeigen dir alles ganz genau im aufregenden Detail, Großaufnahmen und HD selbst 3D Fotzen Sex wird angeboten.

  54. Gibt es das wirklich, dachte ich, nur fürs zuschauen?


Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *